Now it's not entirely clear exactly what Tagliata even is to be honest, nor therefore how it should be cooked. The word itself seems to mean just 'cut', but in Pisa (and I think more widely in Tuscany, the great meat eating heart of Italy) it's a sirloin, t-bone or fillet steak that has been very simply pan cooked or grilled and served with either plenty of olive oil and rosemary or fresh rocket and shavings of parmesan. I had both types in Pisa (well you can't get too much of a good thing :-), and once we'd got to Corsica for the next stage of our holiday I decided to try and recreate it for supper one night. However the most critical thing about Tagliata is not how it's cooked, but more how it's served. They cut the meat off the bone and then into fine strips which are often served on a sharing platter.
The first Tagliata I had in "I Santi", Pisa. So busy eating it I almost forgot to photograph it.
Personally I think there are just three things you have to remember for a great steak, whatever it might be called.
- The meat needs to be room temperature before you start, so take it out of the fridge at least an hour before, it not more.
- Season with plenty of salt & pepper (but only do this at the last minute before cooking)
- Keep the heat high (so if frying in particular use a heavy based pan)
There's a fourth too I guess, but it's more of a general rule with all meat so I didn't include it - let the meat rest!
Timing wise I can struggle with steak sometimes, and will often serve it under cooked rather than over cooked. Personally I prefer my meat that way (hell, I'll often taste it raw just to check it's OK!) but I'm not sure all my guests agree. I tend to use the pressing technique to gauge how cooked a steak is, i.e. just press my finger into the meat and you can usually tell by how much it springs back how much it is cooked. With thicker steaks this can prove difficult though.
Anyhow, enough warbling - here's a short video of me (warning - contains moderate nudity!) trying to cook this in Corsica in the apartment we rented in Bastia. I was getting all Keith Floyd to start, but unfortunately the camera woman hadn't pressed the record button, so we lost that bit, though you might think that's a good thing depending on your attitude to Keith Floyd ...